Try 1x for free
1x is a curated photo gallery where every image have been handpicked for their high quality. With a membership, you can take part in the curation process and also try uploading your own best photos and see if they are good enough to make it all the way.
Right now you get one month for free when signing up for a PRO account. You can cancel anytime without being charged.
Try for free   No thanks
Magazine
Is Photography Art or a craft ?

by Editor Colin Dixon
Edited and published by Yvette Depaepe, the 4th of August 2023 

 

'Avec la mer du Nord' by Desmet Patrick



This came to my attention at a Camera Club talk in the UK when a presenter stated “remember photography is not art”.

This resonated with me as my feelings had always been I was creating art in my photography.

 

What is the description of art?
In the Oxford Dictionary it is “The expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power.”

So from the above description I would say we photographers can and do produce works of beauty and emotional power.  This has been a question since the beginning of photography. In fact today this is still a question.  Google “What is art “ and you get the 7 types of art :
Painting.
Sculpture.
Literature.
Architecture.
Cinema.
Music.
Theatre.

But then there are the 8 forms of art which includes photography.

So let us look at both sides of the argument.
There are people who assert that a still photograph is never art, while there are others who assert that photography is considered art under the right circumstances, but that not every photograph taken is automatically considered a work of art.

 

 

'Vision'  by Hans-Wolfgang Hawerkamp

 


NOT ART
For a long time after its invention, people considered photography only as a skill and a tool for documentation.

At an early meeting of the Photographic Society of London, established in 1853, one of the members complained that the new technique was "too literal to compete with works of art" because it was unable to "elevate the imagination". This conception of photography is a mechanical operation of you pressing a shutter and technology recording an image of what was a moment in time, sometimes described as looking through a window at life. Another argument would be photography captures reality rather than creating a subjective reality, which is what “real art” does.

 

 

'Desir d’existence 1/5'  by Sebastien DEL GROSSO

 


PHOTOGRAPHY AS ART (of course it is)
As discussed this argument is still alive as any Google search will tell you.
But over time since the beginnings of photography more and more people regard photography as ART.

The development of photography as an art form happened quickly. But, what made photography an art form in the first place was the application of science in the creation of art. What types of photography are art? The answers are as limitless as with any other medium. Just as a painter uses paint, a brush, and a canvas, the photography uses a camera and computers/dark room as their tools.
I
t is plain to see that a carefully composed, exposed captured image has inherent artistic value. Photography, as a medium, can shade reality with new context and meaning. Messages and surrealism can be conveyed through the presentation of a still image. The juxtaposition of visual elements can take on new value when frozen in time as a photograph. All of the near-infinite photographic variables and possibilities make it clear that photography is artistic.

 

Over time, barriers to artistic acceptance have been eroded and the pretentious protection of “traditional art” has lessened (but not dead). We here in 1X are definitely artists and this site proves 100% what great artists can do with our tools and technology. 

LET US ALL CREATE AND ENJOY OUR ART HERE ON 1X.

 

 

'Harmony of Feelings' by Juliana Nan

 

 

'Wavy spiral' by Vangelis Makris (Mc Ris)

 

'The Golden Zebra Body' by Kristian Liebrand

 

 

'Lady’s Man' by The Gar – Geir Jartveit

 

 

'Art Lovers.' by Ben Goossens

 

 

'Year 2020' by Sulaiman Almawash

 

 

'Lost Soul Forever' by Nick Amanda

 

 

n/t by Vladimir Tikhorskiy 

 

 

n/t by Radik Driben

 

 

'Lines' by Asef Azimaie

 

 

'The Selfie' by Victoria Glinka

 

 

'Twisted Roof (Eternal shadows I)' by Oussama Mazouz

 

 

'Artic Fox' by Georg Scharf

 

 

'Goldfingers' by Edith Hoffman

 

 

'An ill wind' by Adrian Donoghue

 

Write
Wonderful gallery and thank you so much for including my creation :-)
感谢科林的精彩写作。自进入1x后见识多了,真是众多的大师值得我学习
Wonderful gallery and thank you so much for including my creation :-)
...stunning and impressive gallery, and interesting article...
Very interesting subject. "Photography, as a medium, can shade reality with new context and meaning" therefore "L'art photographique" . More often though people consider photography what is really COMPUTER ART BY MEANS OF PHOTOGRAPHY which is not photography per se. Computer art is further divided by its goal: illustration, poster, commercial, adds....
Great article and brilliant images that illustrates the content.Congratulations! <3
Absolutely magic! Thank you Colin and dearest Yvette.
Al credits go to Colin, but YES, glad to publish such good articles ;-)
Thank you Iris glad you enjoyed it.
An ally at last! Well done, Colin.
Thank you Lauren's :)
A thoughtful article accentuated with excellent masterpieces. Thank you Colin and Yvette!
Thanks for your appreciation, Hans. This is a TOP article by Colin, indeed !
Yes we have amazing works of Art right here :)
Fascinating images worthy of being pieces of art! Thank you for sharing
Great article and amazing photo gallery to illustrate it. Thank you, Colin and Yvette!
Thank you Ludmila
Thank you, dear Ludmila. I love this article too and am proud to present it in the magazine ;-)
Colin, I love this excellent article of yours, which resonates with my July article "Creative Photography: a modern contemporary art form". Wonderful collection of photographs. Many thanks to you Colin and Yvette for publishing it.
Thank you Miro loving your articles :)
Thanks for your neverlasting appreciation, dear Miro!
I like very much, stunning work, splendid images, congrats !!!
Thank you Thierry
Great article and thought provoking ideas, excellent images selected to prove the discussion.
Thank you Chris
Stunning artworks, congratulations to all photographers whose work has been showcased, Thanks Colin for wonderful write up
Thanks Anita
thanks a lot Colin for this much interesting article. I definitely see my photography as an artistic form of expression. Also many thanks to Yvette, regards Hans-Wolfgang
Hear Hear Hans it certainly is :)
Thank you for your neverlasting appreciation, Hans-Wolfgang ;-)