Try 1x for free
1x is a curated photo gallery where every image have been handpicked for their high quality. With a membership, you can take part in the curation process and also try uploading your own best photos and see if they are good enough to make it all the way.
Right now you get one month for free when signing up for a PRO account. You can cancel anytime without being charged.
Try for free   No thanks
Forum
Critique
Torch Festival
#FIRE#PEOPLE
Xiao Ping PRO
2 months ago
This is a photo taken in a small village in southern China, where the Torch Festival is being celebrated.
This is a drone photograph. When taking this photo, I was accustomed to using aperture priority mode during the day and forgot to switch to shutter priority mode at night, resulting in a relatively slow shutter speed of only 1/8 second.
Do you have any suggestions for improving this photo? Thank you.

 
Chengrui PRO
2 months ago

Dear Xiao Ping

It's nice to meet u in this forum. Happy New Year TO YOU

As you said, your shutter speed is very slow, but I think it is irrelevant, because it makes the flame have a beautiful shape. When I first saw the picture, I saw a snake, thinking that this year is the year of the snake, so I decided to focus the photo on the line of the flame transmission.

First of all, I removed the color, which I think is the interference factor of this work. After removing the color, the brightness of the flame is obvious, which makes it a main visual guide. Meanwhile, I cut out the unnecessary parts, which makes the composition more compact. If other reviewers see it they should give you a better idea.

At the same time, I noticed that the screen of the mobile phone where we shot the "snake" was bright, so I prepared to take it as a highlight. I used the mask tool to select the mass part separately, lowered the brightness, and increased the highlight, so that the mobile phone screen was removed

I lowered the overall contrast and increased the gray level to make it look less clashing.

Of course I think you should read the opinions of other critics, because my ideas are just my preferences, maybe there will be a better direction.

thank u

Chengrui

 

 

Edited: 2 months ago by Chengrui
Cicek Kiral CREW 
2 months ago — Senior critic

Hello, Xiao 

Welcome to our forum and thank you for uploading your image. You have a rich portfolio indeed. This festival looks quiet interesting. The gathering of so many people adds richness to this cultural event. It is really a pity that the highlights in the flames are blown and the texture is immensly lost. Although the color red stands out and seems to be important in terms of the festivities, I think it is too much saturated. You might think to reduce the saturation slightly. As to recover the texture in the flames you should try to reduce highlights in the flames very carefully so as not to end up with unnaturally looking flames. You might add some texture from some other fire image after reducing the brightness using clone stamp maybe. Otherwise I like your image.I wish you good light...Cicek

Xiao Ping PRO
2 months ago
Cicek Kiral CREW 

Hello, Xiao 

Welcome to our forum and thank you for uploading your image. You have a rich portfolio indeed. This festival looks quiet interesting. The gathering of so many people adds richness to this cultural event. It is really a pity that the highlights in the flames are blown and the texture is immensly lost. Although the color red stands out and seems to be important in terms of the festivities, I think it is too much saturated. You might think to reduce the saturation slightly. As to recover the texture in the flames you should try to reduce highlights in the flames very carefully so as not to end up with unnaturally looking flames. You might add some texture from some other fire image after reducing the brightness using clone stamp maybe. Otherwise I like your image.I wish you good light...Cicek

Thank you for your valuable feedback.

Xiao Ping PRO
2 months ago
Chengrui PRO

Dear Xiao Ping

It's nice to meet u in this forum. Happy New Year TO YOU

As you said, your shutter speed is very slow, but I think it is irrelevant, because it makes the flame have a beautiful shape. When I first saw the picture, I saw a snake, thinking that this year is the year of the snake, so I decided to focus the photo on the line of the flame transmission.

First of all, I removed the color, which I think is the interference factor of this work. After removing the color, the brightness of the flame is obvious, which makes it a main visual guide. Meanwhile, I cut out the unnecessary parts, which makes the composition more compact. If other reviewers see it they should give you a better idea.

At the same time, I noticed that the screen of the mobile phone where we shot the "snake" was bright, so I prepared to take it as a highlight. I used the mask tool to select the mass part separately, lowered the brightness, and increased the highlight, so that the mobile phone screen was removed

I lowered the overall contrast and increased the gray level to make it look less clashing.

Of course I think you should read the opinions of other critics, because my ideas are just my preferences, maybe there will be a better direction.

thank u

Chengrui

 

 

Thank you for your valuable feedback.