Try 1x for free
1x is a curated photo gallery where every image have been handpicked for their high quality. With a membership, you can take part in the curation process and also try uploading your own best photos and see if they are good enough to make it all the way.
Right now you get one month for free when signing up for a PRO account. You can cancel anytime without being charged.
Try for free   No thanks
We use cookies
This website uses cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience for the following purposes: to enable basic functionality of the website, to provide a better experience on the website, to measure your interest in our products and services and to personalize marketing interactions.
I agree   I deny
Forum
Critique
Street - Night Photography
#NIGHT
Guy Sapir PRO
1 year ago

Hi friends and dear critics

Please look at the attached photo and let me know how you think it can be improved.

The exif are:

Exposure  - 1/80 sec

F Number - F/4

Focal - 14mm

ISO - 3200

 

I'm very happy with the biker location and the fact that he smeers a little bit.

My problem is with the photo is that leading lines and the focus point lead the eye away from the interesting area of the photo.

Appreciate your thoughts.

Thanks

Guy

 

Steven T CREW 
1 year ago — Senior critic

Guy,

 

Thanks for posting the photo here in Critique.  It's an interesting night shot.  Isn't it amazing that we can shoot at a high ISO like 3200 with so little noise?  I still remember the film days when 160 ASA was considered 'High Speed'.  Later we got 400 ASA.  The grain was like 'connecting the dots'.  Ahh,  nostalgia. 

 

You wrote that "leading lines and the focus point lead the eye away from the interesting area of the photo".   If the bicycle and rider are the important subject, then a closer crop and possible a left-to-right flip could be tried.  If the end of the street is where you want viewers to go, then darkening the left side and brightening the right is a possiblity.  Photoshop Gradient could do that.  Photoshop keeps changing as it updates, and I notice that to get the familar Gradient tools you have to find and click 'Classic Gradient'.  Then 'Linear Dodge' and Linear Burn' reappear.   Another option are the Gradient tools in 'Filter>Camera Raw Filter>Masking'

 

I tried a quick edit for a screen capture  - darkening the bicycle and brightening the end of the street.  Viewers who 'read' an image left to right will be drawn by the strong leading line of the sidewalk towards the bright lights at the end.  The bicycle rider seems to be in a hurry to get away - that adds some tension and mystery to the image.  Was that the effect you wanted?  Adding noise or grain can sometimes add drama to a Film Noir style black and white photo.  Is the photo to be 'Untitled', or did you have one in mind?

 

. . . .  Steven, senior critic

 

 

Edited: 1 year ago by Steven T
Daniel Springgay CREW 
1 year ago — Senior critic

Hi Guy I see Steven T has already given you some wonderful feedback well done steven. This is my take on your fine image I love the leading lines of composition so I have not changed the faming. I have gone for pure Stark Power. Some dodge work to lighten up the street. - Selected the cycling man and added motion blurr - Nik Tools Clear View +50 for the texture power. Just a few ideas for you to think about...

 

 

Udo Dittmann PRO
1 year ago

Hello Guy,

 

this is my try with a little dodge and burn to get something like a dark film scene.

 

Greetings

Udo

Edited: 1 year ago by Udo Dittmann
Guy Sapir PRO
1 year ago
Steven T CREW 

Guy,

 

Thanks for posting the photo here in Critique.  It's an interesting night shot.  Isn't it amazing that we can shoot at a high ISO like 3200 with so little noise?  I still remember the film days when 160 ASA was considered 'High Speed'.  Later we got 400 ASA.  The grain was like 'connecting the dots'.  Ahh,  nostalgia. 

 

You wrote that "leading lines and the focus point lead the eye away from the interesting area of the photo".   If the bicycle and rider are the important subject, then a closer crop and possible a left-to-right flip could be tried.  If the end of the street is where you want viewers to go, then darkening the left side and brightening the right is a possiblity.  Photoshop Gradient could do that.  Photoshop keeps changing as it updates, and I notice that to get the familar Gradient tools you have to find and click 'Classic Gradient'.  Then 'Linear Dodge' and Linear Burn' reappear.   Another option are the Gradient tools in 'Filter>Camera Raw Filter>Masking'

 

I tried a quick edit for a screen capture  - darkening the bicycle and brightening the end of the street.  Viewers who 'read' an image left to right will be drawn by the strong leading line of the sidewalk towards the bright lights at the end.  The bicycle rider seems to be in a hurry to get away - that adds some tension and mystery to the image.  Was that the effect you wanted?  Adding noise or grain can sometimes add drama to a Film Noir style black and white photo.  Is the photo to be 'Untitled', or did you have one in mind?

 

. . . .  Steven, senior critic

 

 

Steven T CREW 

Guy,

 

Thanks for posting the photo here in Critique.  It's an interesting night shot.  Isn't it amazing that we can shoot at a high ISO like 3200 with so little noise?  I still remember the film days when 160 ASA was considered 'High Speed'.  Later we got 400 ASA.  The grain was like 'connecting the dots'.  Ahh,  nostalgia. 

 

You wrote that "leading lines and the focus point lead the eye away from the interesting area of the photo".   If the bicycle and rider are the important subject, then a closer crop and possible a left-to-right flip could be tried.  If the end of the street is where you want viewers to go, then darkening the left side and brightening the right is a possiblity.  Photoshop Gradient could do that.  Photoshop keeps changing as it updates, and I notice that to get the familar Gradient tools you have to find and click 'Classic Gradient'.  Then 'Linear Dodge' and Linear Burn' reappear.   Another option are the Gradient tools in 'Filter>Camera Raw Filter>Masking'

 

I tried a quick edit for a screen capture  - darkening the bicycle and brightening the end of the street.  Viewers who 'read' an image left to right will be drawn by the strong leading line of the sidewalk towards the bright lights at the end.  The bicycle rider seems to be in a hurry to get away - that adds some tension and mystery to the image.  Was that the effect you wanted?  Adding noise or grain can sometimes add drama to a Film Noir style black and white photo.  Is the photo to be 'Untitled', or did you have one in mind?

 

. . . .  Steven, senior critic

 

 

Thank you so much Steven for your reply.

I think I did not make myself quite clear. The leading I believe take the viewers eyes to the far-right end of the photo. The interesting part to me is the man on the bicycle who as you said "seems to be in a hurry to get away" you suggested cropping but would ruing the composition. I was asked to keep to a 5:7 crop ratio.
I wonder of I should darken the rider as you dis and make him a complete silhouette or leave some details on him.
Again, many thanks for your thoughts.
Guy

Guy Sapir PRO
1 year ago
Daniel Springgay CREW 

Hi Guy I see Steven T has already given you some wonderful feedback well done steven. This is my take on your fine image I love the leading lines of composition so I have not changed the faming. I have gone for pure Stark Power. Some dodge work to lighten up the street. - Selected the cycling man and added motion blurr - Nik Tools Clear View +50 for the texture power. Just a few ideas for you to think about...

 

 

Thank you Daniel.
I really like the motion blur that you have added. 

It may be a bit too much fo rmy liking but a wanderful idea.

Thanks so much.

Guy Sapir PRO
1 year ago
Udo Dittmann PRO

Hello Guy,

 

this is my try with a little dodge and burn to get something like a dark film scene.

 

Greetings

Udo

Thanks a lot Udo.

Intersting approuch.

Much aprreciated.

Guy