1x.com - First aid by Michael Knudsen

Photos Artists Forum Tutorials Critique Books Buy Prints About

Stumble 1X

Tour

Join

Sign in

First aid

Related photos

Write

Michael Knudsen 6 months ago

I can see that there are problems with removing my image, so I have tried to make a suggestion for improvement and made a reupload.
The intention of the image was only to make you smile, therefore the category of humor.

Best Michael

Michael Knudsen 6 months ago

Thanks Ben

I have decided not to reupload.
I only want the best for 1x and i will try another image in the humour category :-) Only a small comment, this image was not uploaded in the category "Creative edit" but in the category "humour"
So, please remove the image when you is able to do it.
Have a nice day.

Ben Goossens 6 months ago

I will contact the right person to remove the image Michael.
I asked Michael via OE mail to upload a corrected version.

We ALL can make a mistake, but negative reactions are not very fair on published image, we can do this on ALL published images all kind... therefore is Critique Forum.
Please, stop all comments it creates an unpleasant situation IMO

Success with your corrected version Michael.

Best, ben

Brian Brinch I just want to ask if I understand you correct? You mean that it's not allowed to give negative comments to any published photo on 1x? Only positive comments are welcome? Hmmmmm, don't agree about that.

Sven Fennema I agree with you Ben on comments in bad language or offending ones, but I really have to say that I always appreciate honesty most and I find this very important. And that's same on my own image, I love criticial comments and also negative ones, actually even one of these more than 5 which only are "+++"

Michael Knudsen 6 months ago

Breaking news :-)

I have just asked 1x to remove my photo, I will give it a try some other time.

michael

Joram Wolters I have an immense respect for you for taking this step, as others have said before, you have an impressive track record, its just that this single image has some serious flaws to it. I tip my hat to you sir.

Kent Mathiesen Respect, but take you time, and make another version. I love your idea, and would like to see it in-proved version.

Regards Kent.

Willem de Vlaming Respect from me for that step Michael.

Björn Billing It takes integrity to do that - kudos to you Michael!

Michael Knudsen :-)

David Leyland Keep producing the wonderful images you have in your portfolio. Regards David

David Leyland 6 months ago

We all have good days and bad days and looking at the rest of your portfolio you have some very good days indeed. Don't let the odd few comments stop you.

Anita Meezen 6 months ago

Like many here I also think that the idea is funny but the post processing is not. I've seen you're other work here... great images! It's just this picture that is not so good.

Jeannette Oerlemans 6 months ago

It's great fun idea is Michael, but the edit is less. Next time you just think! :)

Michael Knudsen I will be sorry if I only just think and not do photographs any more :-(

Jeannette Oerlemans I mean, just better next time. Google translator is sometimes so weird. :) And it seems the turn briefly to get my reaction. :) Yes it! We are all there to learn and I, even I make mistakes and I see things that are wrong in a picture and I think it's very nice if I can be alerted.
This, I feel much better than if everyone would say it's good. And here we learn again, so I said the next time. Think of it as constructive and not as a criticism. So I mean it.

asal 6 months ago

Hehe ! So nice !

Marian Korte 6 months ago

I'am sorry Michael, I agree with lars Holmgaard. Love your creative idea, but its not well done:(

Francesco Fratto 6 months ago

:) Nobody is perfect!

Michael Knudsen 6 months ago

Hej keller
Det er ok, jeg har uploadet en bedre version (håber jeg) på min webside :-) og retter den her når jeg får mulighed for upload.
mvh mic

keller 6 months ago

Hej Michael
jeg er stort set på samme linje som de andre
men dine ideer er rigtig gode :)
Mvh Keller

Michael Knudsen 6 months ago

I am glad you like it :-)
I am sorry you do not like it :-(
Thank you for all comments, I respect your opinion about "first aid". I agree with some of your critics and hope it will help me to do better next time. We all have something to learn, especially me this time.
With respect
Michael

Lars Holmgaard I totally respect that.

Michael Knudsen :-)

Lars Holmgaard 6 months ago

I am sorry to say it and it has nothing to do with the photographer, so please don't take it personal, but I agree with most of the comments below. The idea of the image is okay, but the manipulation itself is bad. Really, really bad indeed. The overall color temperature, contrast and general looks of the big man and the small worker is completely different which makes it look very artificial. The small worker is looking at the wrong point, he is not looking at the arrow for sure. There is a difference in the angles between the man on the ladder and the big man and the nose has a weird shape at the top, where the ladder is placed. Remember, this is not to be rude or disrespectful. I am just pointing out the flaws as I see them.

Brian Brinch I have to agree with Lars here. This photo does not reach the usual high standards for pictures on 1x. Amazing how it was finding a way through the screening process.

Lars Holmgaard Exactly. It is important to mention that the photographer is quite innocent here. It is the fact that a picture of this quality can be accepted on 1x that I am criticizing.

ariel caliex 6 months ago

Goods Idea

Steen Bugtrup 6 months ago

Not good at all.. but nice idea, need more work.

luceombra 6 months ago

Nice work!

David Leyland 6 months ago

Sorry Michael I tend to agree the workman is flat and lacking contrast in relation to the main figure and the back part of the ladder is visible when it should be behind the nose.