Mel Brackstone 2 months ago

I love this image, wish I'd taken it!

Karen Khontyan 1 year ago

super. :)

sasson haviv 2 years ago

very good

R. Lee Harrell 2 years ago

Not sure why you're so bitter... it was published.

Darko Pavlovic 2 years ago

I would love to see the portfolio of the people posting that kind of comments.. :)
I like this photo...

Steve Hill 2 years ago

I'm not sure if it's good form to post comments as "stupid" (even though do I agree that comments can be stupid). I agree the colors look washed out and I kinda don't get the picture... I mean, I'm 89% there but not a 100%. Anyway...let people have their opinion and just speak poorly of them behind their backs...as God intended.

Monique 2 years ago

haha
superb
like from a movie!

Guro Storskjær 2 years ago

Nice!!
Reminds me of Gregory Crewdson!
I love it! This i conseptual art on it's best :)

snehula 2 years ago

I dont understand the comment about not understanding what's happening :-D the story seems pretty obvious and nicely told, and yeah I can understand your feelings about the comments.. still, just marking them stupid and posting it here is kinda humiliating, not the best solution either.. u could have explained why u don't agree with them coz those people who wrote them obviously don't see it.. (just a suggestion)
poorly exposed? i don't think there is any place in the photo where u wouldn't be able to make out details in the dark tones and since this is supposed to be an evening picture (although u probably shot it in daylight, sorry if i'm mistaken), what are u expecting sunlight?
washed out color: which one of you people can see colours in the dark? i say u still see more colors here than u would in reality in an evening hour
etc..

well i'm really sorry for the possibly stupid comment :-)))
anyway, u did a really nice job, like it

Ayatullah R. Hiba 2 years ago

Excellent.great consept!

RICHARD20D 2 years ago

I like this image because its different. BUT... there are a few people on 1x who become so obsessed about technical deatail they forget to look at the picture with an open mind. Some people need to look beyond the iso, f/stop camera model/ lighting and just look at the image as a picture taken by someone else that proberly has a completely differnt view as what makes a photograph. This to me is a brilliant site, with some fantastic photographers, great forums and interesting people, but like everwhere else there are a few people who only like a certain type of image and anything outside that box confuses them.

Regards Richard

Peter Kemp 2 years ago

great shot .. great story ...it is YOU who is the artist and creates the scenens so have fun and keep enjoying me with these great pics ..complimetnsn for your work!

cheers Peter

Kenneth Svedlund 2 years ago

This is a nice shot, and I think that you are correct. There are a lot of comments here during screening that are out of line. People are trying so hard sometimes to comment it gets ridiculous.
This is a good photograph and the colors are just right.

Sieger Joostens 2 years ago

I like your work, but don't think you're too good to get any critic. Nobody, ever, is too good for critic... You're the one being stupid, I'm sorry to say.

Diego Bardone 2 years ago

You got it published so you should be happy. I'm not one of the so called stupids but reading what you wrote I'd be pleased to be one of them...

Corrado Chiozzi 2 years ago

I didn't see this photo in screeneng, just now i see and I like it !!
But... "STUPID Comments from members during screening"?? I think that everyone say what think about a photo, is just a personal thought, is not stupid. I hope that is not a stupid comment also my.
Anyway, my compliments for the photo.
Corrado

lbaia 2 years ago

I like the concept, congratulations.
Having said so (and I didn't vote for or against it) I think you should remove your comment about the "STUPID" comments.
This is not what 1x is about.
BR,
Luis

Ludovic Charbonneau 2 years ago

"STUPID Comments from members during screening"
Tu change pas toi ;o}

Patrizia Burra 2 years ago

Very very nice...

Lachlan Kent 2 years ago

Brilliantly exposed, so much depth, colours so appropriate and evocative. Background on left adds to the mystery and perplexity.

Kusoglu Ali 2 years ago

Excellent

Phyllis Clarke 2 years ago

The cold night, and the warm light that beckons only for some - while others wish...A wonderful way to show this sensitive subject. Congratulations. Phyllis

Pierre Pageau 2 years ago

félicitations .